How to pick upsets in March Madness
Pick a few, in the right spots. About one first-round game in four is an upset, and most of them live in the same few matchups.
Where first-round upsets live, since 1985.
Five rules, from the seed math
- Start with the 12-over-5 game. It hits about 35 times in 100.
- Add an 11 seed over a 6 seed. About 39 in 100, since 1985.
- Take two or three first-round upsets. That matches history without betting the bracket.
- Stop before the late rounds. Favorites rule late. Keep your champion a 1 or 2 seed.
- Never spend a pick on 16 over 1. Twice, ever, in 164 tries.
Treat the 8-vs-9 game as a coin flip, not an upset.
One low seed in your Sweet 16 is normal. Two is a story.
A worked example
Say you take two 12 seeds and one 11 seed.
Each pick hits about 35 to 39 times in 100.
Together, the chance at least one lands is about 3 in 4.
Your other 29 first-round picks can stay safe.
One landed upset beats every all-favorite bracket on that game.
How our picker does it
Our picker scores every team by seed strength.
A 5 seed starts at 24. A 12 seed starts at 10.
Your chaos answer hands the lower seed a bonus.
Turn chaos up, and the 12 seed can pass the 5.
Turn it down, and the favorite holds.
New to seeds? Start with what a seed is.
Five questions start your bracket. Your picks finish it.
Our picker opens on Selection Sunday, March 14, 2027. Five answers start your bracket. You can flip any pick. Free forever, no ads, no accounts.
Common questions
How many upsets should I pick in my bracket?
Two or three in the first round is the normal range. Since 1985, about one first-round game in four is an upset, but they cluster in a few matchups, like the 12 seed against the 5 seed.
Should I pick a 16 seed to beat a 1 seed?
History says no. A 16 seed has beaten a 1 seed twice in 164 tries: UMBC in 2018 and Fairleigh Dickinson in 2023. It is a fun pick that almost always costs you a game.
More bracket basics
- How to fill out a March Madness bracket
- What is a March Madness bracket?
- How does bracket scoring work?
- What is a Cinderella team?
- When is Selection Sunday 2027?
- How often do upsets happen?
- Which first-round upsets happen most often?
- How often does a 12 seed beat a 5 seed?
- How often does an 11 seed beat a 6 seed?
- How often does a 10 seed beat a 7 seed?
- How often does a 13 seed beat a 4 seed?
- What is a seed in March Madness?
- What is March Madness?
- Has anyone ever had a perfect bracket?
- Fill out a bracket if you know nothing about basketball
- What is the Final Four?
- How many teams are in March Madness?
- What is the opening round in March Madness?
- What is the Sweet 16?
- What is the Elite Eight?
- How many games are in March Madness?
- What is an automatic bid?
- What is an at-large bid?
- What is a bubble team?
- What is bracketology?
- How many rounds are in March Madness?
- What is the NIT?
- What is a conference tournament?
- What are NET rankings?
- What is a bid stealer?
- What is the selection committee?
- What is Wins Above Bubble?
- How often does a double-digit seed make the Final Four?
- Fill a mock bracket today
Make your calls on the eight matchups waiting on the home page.